CCTV analyst struggles to explain footage in lawyer's murder trial
Crime and Justice
By
Julius Chepkwony
| Nov 19, 2026
A government forensic analyst came under intense scrutiny at the High Court in Narok after struggling to explain crucial events captured in CCTV footage presented as evidence in the murder trial of lawyer Mandela Nabaala Leyian.
Assistant Superintendent of Police Sawe Kigen, who was called by the prosecution to analyse and interpret the surveillance footage, was taken to task over his inability to identify individuals, establish their movements and reconstruct the sequence of events leading to the fatal shooting outside Mara Junction Club in Narok.
The hearing, presided over by Justice Charles Kariuki, witnessed a tense exchange as defence lawyer Harrison Kinyanjui subjected the forensic analyst to sustained cross-examination, questioning what he described as glaring omissions, selective interpretation and failure to examine critical sections of the recordings.
The prosecution, led by Ms Kerubo, presented the analyst to explain the CCTV evidence, but his testimony exposed significant gaps in the interpretation of the footage.
Kinyanjui pressed Sawe to explain the movements of the accused, Dr Kanyinke Sena, from his vehicle towards the deceased's car, as well as the commotion that preceded the shouting heard in the recordings during the shooting on July 12, 2025, outside Mara Junction Night Club in Narok Town.
READ MORE
Certificate deals widen Kenya's seafarers access to global fleets
Half-truths: Ruto defends record but struggles to address the pain of cost of living
Kenya moves closer to naming its crude oil ahead of first oil production
Safety crisis deepens as building collapses claim 38 lives in 11 months
The price of success: Kilimani's property boom leaves area's old souls bitter
Delayed ship donation spotlights Kenya's seafarer training crisis
Firm to build geothermal-powered fertiliser plant at Olkaria Energy Park
KCB profits surge to Sh57.1b on strong regional performance
How Zanzibar's Fumba rose from a community to a booming city
Ruto defends economic record as public debt climbs to Sh13.5 trillion
But the analyst struggled to distinguish the individuals appearing in the footage and explain who was doing what during the confrontation.
The defence accused him of overlooking substantial portions of the recordings while failing to account for movements that it argued were clearly visible.
At one point, the witness was challenged to identify a person seen running towards the accused's vehicle but reportedly described the individual as a stranger, raising questions about the depth and accuracy of his forensic examination.
Kinyanjui accused the analyst of attempting to fit "square pegs in round holes", arguing that his interpretation was unreliable and offered little assistance to the court in establishing what actually happened.
The defence further questioned the credibility of the forensic examination after Sawe acknowledged that the equipment and software used to analyse the CCTV recordings were outdated and had inherent limitations.
Kinyanjui challenged the witness on whether the technological shortcomings had compromised the reliability of his findings, particularly given his inability to identify individuals and reconstruct critical movements captured by the surveillance cameras.
The lawyer argued that the analyst had failed to examine significant sections of the recordings and had not adequately explained movements that could help the court establish how the confrontation unfolded.
The admission over the outdated equipment and software added another dimension to the defence's attack on the prosecution's forensic evidence.
In another significant admission during cross-examination, Sawe acknowledged that he had not arrived at a conclusive finding on how the incident unfolded, leaving key questions surrounding the fatal confrontation unanswered.
The exchange placed the evidential value of the CCTV analysis under fresh scrutiny, with the defence maintaining that the prosecution's expert had failed to provide a coherent reconstruction of the events leading to the killing.
More than a year after the deadly confrontation outside the popular entertainment spot left one person dead and another facing a murder charge, the trial continues to expose sharply competing accounts of what happened that night.
The trial commenced on March 10, 2026, before Justice Kariuki. The prosecution's first witness, Santeyion Lemusia, a watchman at Mara Junction Club, told the court that he rushed outside after hearing a gunshot and found Dr Sena standing near the driver's door of his vehicle holding a pistol.
He said the deceased was nearby, holding his neck and appearing unable to speak. A sword, he testified, was lying on the ground close to the deceased.
"When I heard the bullet shot, I rushed to the scene and found the two standing adjacent to each other. The victim was standing holding his neck, trying to speak but unable to do so, while the accused was also standing facing him," Lemusia told the court.
Another prosecution witness, Ambrose Lelesit, the proprietor of the nightclub, testified that he knew both men but had never seen them together before the incident.
During cross-examination by defence lawyer Gordon Ogado, Lelesit described Dr Sena as a long-time customer who had never caused trouble at his establishments in Narok and Bomet.
"I knew the accused for a long time and he never caused trouble in any of my establishments in Narok and Bomet," he told the court.
Lelesit further testified that immediately after the shooting, Dr Sena told him that the deceased had attempted to attack him with a sword.
He added that the accused did not attempt to flee after the shooting. The witness said the shooting occurred near the driver's side door of Dr Sena's vehicle, claiming that the deceased was advancing towards the vehicle while armed with a sword.
He further told the court that the sword's sheath remained inside the deceased's vehicle, which was parked about five metres from the scene.
The prosecution produced the sword as an exhibit, with Lemusia identifying it as the weapon he said had been picked up by the deceased's friend and placed inside the deceased's vehicle before the injured man was rushed to hospital.
The defence has maintained that the shooting occurred in circumstances of immediate danger and that Dr Sena acted in lawful self-defence after allegedly facing a sword attack.
The trial is scheduled to continue from November 17 to 19, with further examination of the CCTV recordings and forensic evidence expected to take centre stage as the prosecution and defence seek to advance their respective accounts of the fatal confrontation.
MOST READ
Certificate deals widen Kenya's seafarers access to global fleets
SHIPPING & LOGISTICS
By Philip Mwakio