✕

Why Ruto's State of the Nation address fails to capture Kenya's reality

Barrack Muluka
By Barrack Muluka | Nov 22, 2026
President William Ruto during his  State of the Nation Address at Parliament, Nairobi on November 18,2026. [Elvis Ogina, Standard]

Government is an instrument intended to secure human ends. The American Declaration of Independence (1776) reminds us that government is ultimately about human flourishing. It is not a producer of material prosperity, important as that may be. This is a fundamental starting point for every State of the Nation address, anywhere in the world.

Focused as they often are on woolly materialistic optics and masks, many leaders tend to lose sight of this, especially when they want to look good ahead of elections. Kenya’s William Ruto has missed the bull’s eye once again.

On Wednesday, the Head of State and Government failed to remember that government is about securing the people’s rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. He forgot that governments are removed and replaced when they fail this test.

One question sits quietly beneath every State of the Nation address, no matter where: What is government about? It is a deceptively simple question, yet also a profoundly political one. Governments can build roads, bridges, houses, hospitals, schools and digital platforms. They may increase agricultural production, expand electricity connections and sometimes even increase electricity generation. They may attract investment and report impressive rates of economic growth. They may, in fact, produce thousands of pages of policy documents and millions of statistics. They may announce that the nation is moving forward, faster than ever before.

But none of these things, by themselves, answers the more fundamental question: Moving forward towards what? For governments often move forward towards disaster. They may even say they have done more than any previous regime, sometimes more than all previous regimes put together. But the question does not go away: Done more of what? Sometimes, it is truer to say they have done more harm than any previous regime, or even all of them combined.

More importantly, there is the question of movement towards whose good. This is the question that President Ruto's latest State of the Nation address invites us to ask. The President presented a Kenya of “remarkable achievement and rapid transformation”. The language was confident, expansive and triumphalist. In some respects, the last four years appeared to have produced more progress than previous decades combined. His administration's achievements were presented not merely as substantial, but as historically exceptional.

The reaction was predictable. Some Kenyans laughed. Others scoffed. Some outright accused the President of lying. Others dismissed the speech as political theatre and humbug. And there are undoubtedly Kenyans who genuinely believe that President Ruto has achieved the extraordinary things he claims. In all this, however, the most useful response is perhaps neither laughter nor applause. It is a simple, sober question: What do we mean by progress?

Two hundred and fifty years ago, the American Declaration of Independence offered one of the most influential answers in the political history of the modern world. Its core proposition is astonishingly refreshing.

Human beings possess certain rights from birth. First, they are born equal. Perhaps there is no need to overemphasise this. But, fundamentally, they have a right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Governments are instituted to secure these rights. Accordingly, governments derive their legitimate powers from the consent of the governed. Repeat: “legitimate powers from consent of the governed”.

The language belongs to another time and another political tradition. It also carries the sexist and even racist exclusions and contradictions of 18th-century America. But the underlying proposition is of enormous significance. Government is not an end in itself; it is an instrument. The State does not exist to build, produce GDP or merely balance budgets, as our State of the Nation addresses often suggest. It exists for human beings. Not merely to construct and count houses, roads and other statistics with which a worried incumbent can seek another term.

A government’s legitimacy ultimately rests on whether it secures the conditions under which human beings can live with dignity, freedom, security and a reasonable possibility of happiness. This is what Article 132(1)(c) of the Constitution of Kenya (2010) anticipates by requiring the President to deliver an annual State of the Nation address. The Constitution demands that the President report annually to Parliament on progress made in realising national values and principles. These include transparency, accountability and the rule of law.

This distinction is essential to any serious assessment of the Ruto presidency. There are two different ideas of development competing for our attention. Development can be about production. But, more importantly, it is about human flourishing. Development may ask how much has been produced, assuming it has been produced at all. But it must also ask about the kind of lives people are leading, because the people are the very reason development matters.

The first can be measured in kilometres, tonnes, billions, megawatts, houses, jobs, registrations and percentages, if the figures are true. The second is harder to measure for a government that has been blatant in its abuse of power. It must be measured in dignity, opportunity, security, freedom, health, education, justice and the capacity of citizens to exercise meaningful control over their own lives. Yet, is the first what governments like to count? If it is, the second is what citizens ultimately experience.

Production is fine, if it is happening. Indeed, a country that does not produce cannot flourish. All these things matter: roads, houses, food, factories, technology and jobs. But we would hasten to add that they must have been genuinely achieved, and that the people are not simply being bamboozled with eloquent make-believe. A government that delivers these things deserves recognition. The mistake, however, is twofold. First, it is to imagine that production is itself the definition of development. Second, it is to hallucinate over what does not exist.

A road, if it exists, is not development merely because it exists. It is development if it enables human beings to move, trade, work and live better. A hospital is not development merely because its doors have been opened. A sick citizen must be able to enter it and receive competent treatment without being impoverished. And we could go on and on. The point is that the State of the Nation address provision in the Constitution expects Kenyans to live in dignity, security and liberty. It recognises that a job is not necessarily a livelihood, a source of reasonable security or a path towards a better life. This is the distinction between production and flourishing that Ruto glosses over.

But there is another significant problem. George Orwell understood it long before the language of modern development economics became fashionable. In Animal Farm, the pigs gradually acquire control not merely over the farm but also over the meaning of what happens there. A pig named Squealer is gifted with words and oratory. Even when production falls, he explains why the decline is actually progress.

When food rations are reduced, Squealer explains why the reduction is necessary. The pigs must eat more and eat better so that they can think better and work better for the rest of the animals. Their privileges are indispensable to everyone else's welfare. And there are always statistics. The farm is doing wonderfully, even if the animals are not convinced. The brilliance of Squealer is that he does not necessarily have to invent everything. He only has to select, arrange and interpret. Ruto often does this, perhaps always.

He can announce outputs while leaving outcomes largely unexamined. Take the number of people registered under the Social Health Authority, for example, without addressing how many have benefited or the quality of the services they have received. Or a road that has been completed, without examining the standards to which it was built or its durability. Gradually, the government begins to manufacture both the facts themselves and what those facts mean. As on Orwell’s farm, the country grows while its citizens remain insecure.

Yet even where facts are not manufactured for electoral purposes, a country can become richer while large numbers of its people remain poor. The plantation economies of the colonial world provide some of the starkest examples. Saint-Domingue, before the Haitian Revolution of 1791–1804, was extraordinarily productive and immensely wealthy. Its sugar and coffee plantations generated massive fortunes. But the people producing that wealth were enslaved. While the plantation was rich, the people were not. National wealth and human welfare are not identical concepts. Is there a sense in which countries like Kenya live this way?

Even in a democratic economy, growth can be distributed unevenly. Productivity can rise without wages increasing proportionately. Investment can increase while employment remains precarious. GDP can grow while household purchasing power remains under strain. Government expenditure can expand while public debt becomes increasingly burdensome. A nation can therefore have both an impressive balance sheet and anxious citizens.

And here lies the uncomfortable truth about Kenya in 2026 that Ruto's address skirted around. There are perhaps genuine grounds for saying that the economy has shown resilience. But there are also genuine grounds for concern about poverty, informal employment, fiscal pressures and the distribution of economic gains. The World Bank's recent assessment, for example, describes Kenya's economy as resilient while simultaneously pointing to high public debt, substantial interest obligations, continued fiscal pressures, slow poverty reduction and the dominance of informal employment.

But underlying all this is the question of human rights. This is where the American Declaration offers a critical mirror. If governments are instituted to secure life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, then economic performance cannot be detached from the question of how the State treats its citizens. A government cannot plausibly claim extraordinary development while treating human dignity as an inconvenient obstacle to development. Throughout his tenure, Ruto has attacked the Judiciary for holding his government to account. He says the Judiciary is “slowing down progress”.

A government must ultimately answer for the political culture it creates and the institutions it controls. The Ruto years raise serious questions. Kenya entered the Ruto presidency with a Constitution whose Bill of Rights was designed, among other things, to ensure that the excesses of the old authoritarian State would not return. Kenya’s human rights record over the past four years has been troubling.

The 2024 anti-Finance Bill protests marked a particularly grave moment. Human Rights Watch reported that police used excessive and lethal force. Kenyans saw it, even without NGO reports. At least 60 protesters were killed, according to the Kenya National Commission on Human Rights. Dozens more were reportedly abducted or forcibly disappeared. The pattern did not disappear even after the withdrawal of the Finance Bill.

Human Rights Watch's 2026 country report describes continued killings, abductions, arbitrary arrests and enforced disappearances during 2025. There has also been continuing pressure on journalists, activists, human rights defenders and government critics.

The Ruto government has withheld payments owed to media houses, using what amounts to draconian arm-twisting.

Amnesty International's assessment is similarly grave, describing unlawful and lethal force during demonstrations, enforced disappearances, arbitrary arrests and attacks on freedom of expression and assembly.

This is not merely the language of foreign critics. Kenya's own National Commission on Human Rights has documented persistent extrajudicial killings, enforced disappearances, police brutality and restrictions on civic freedoms. Its 2024/25 reporting recorded a deterioration in the human rights environment and documented complaints involving abductions, arbitrary detention and torture. These are not small blemishes on an otherwise perfect development record. They sit at the heart of the meaning of development itself.

Why, after the promulgation of the 2010 Constitution and decades of struggle against authoritarian rule, have we failed to make the protection of human dignity a settled condition of Kenyan government? This is the more disturbing question to ask after this State of the Nation address.

The Ruto regime is troubling because the constitutional order was supposed to constrain the old logic that encouraged the presidency to be draconian towards citizens. After August 2010, the State was supposed to become more accountable, and the President was required to address Parliament on this every year.

The citizen was supposed to become more sovereign. Security agencies were supposed to become servants of constitutional government rather than instruments of political intimidation.

And yet, in the most intense moments of the Ruto presidency, the old reflexes have resurfaced: protest is treated as disorder; dissent is suspected of conspiracy; activists become threats; critics become enemies; and security becomes the language through which political disagreement is managed.

Ruto dresses up his detractors in abusive and unpresidential language. That is a failure of development in the deepest sense.

When journalists become afraid to report, activists fear abduction, young people fear the police, and families do not know whether a detained relative will return home, there is no development.

Government is instituted to secure life and liberty. A government that celebrates material gains while citizens experience insecurity in their relationship with the State has not fulfilled the whole purpose of government. Ruto’s statistical talk is, of course, focused on elections.

Yet are elections about little more than referendums on the number of government projects, both real and imagined? Are they not, more importantly, judgments on the quality of government?

Ultimately, Kenyans must be encouraged to strive for a constitutional order founded on human dignity, equality, freedom, democracy, social justice, inclusiveness, integrity, transparency and accountability. That is a much larger standard than the one Ruto addresses. It is the standard by which this administration must be judged, and every regime thereafter.

The ultimate purpose of government is not to make itself look successful. It is to secure the conditions under which the governed can live decent, free and meaningful lives.

A country should not just grow richer, if it does; it must actually become better. Whoever makes the next State of the Nation address next year, we will be waiting here.

Share this story
.
RECOMMENDED NEWS